Pastor Henderson joined LifeWay Church in March 2008 as Associate Pastor and was elected Pastor in August 2008. In January 2009, he succeeded Rev. Arthur Potts as Senior Pastor of LifeWay Church. He grew up in Muncie, Indiana and graduated from Jackson College of Ministries (JCM) in Jackson, MS with a Bachelor of Theology.
He also holds a degree in Management Information Systems from Capital University in Columbus and an MBA from Ohio Dominican University. Pastor Henderson met his wife, Becky, at JCM and they married in 1987. Their daughter, Caitlin Tacker, and her family also serve LifeWay Church.